Book review

Cozy Mystery Series Rankings

I’ve posted two book reviews recently and wanted to give a quick ranking of the cozy mystery series I read.

Four series are my favorites. The stories have a decent plot that is well-paced, there are no glaring inconsistencies, and they have well developed animal characters that feature prominently in the story. The authors have a writing style I find enjoyable and they don’t commit two of my pet peeves: constantly using short sentences or trying to prove they own a thesaurus.

  • Cat in the Stacks Mystery by Miranda James (I’ve read 6 books),
  • Magical Cats Mystery by Sofie Kelly (8 books),
  • A Black Cat Bookshop Mystery by Ali Brandon  (5 books),
  • A Bookmobile Cat Mystery by Laurie Cass (4 books).

I just read over at Melissa’s Mocha’s Mystery, and Meows that Twice Told Tail (book #6) will be the final book in the Black Cat Bookshop Mystery series.  😦

The next two series are ok, but not my favorites. I like the writing style of both authors, but there are things I dislike about the books and probably won’t continue with them. 

  • A Southern Ladies Mystery by Miranda James  is a spin-off from the Cat in the Stacks Mystery, but I didn’t enjoy it as much I hoped and stopped after the second book (there are three now). Unlike her Cat in the Stacks Mystery series where the cat Diesel is interesting and well integrated into the story, I don’t think the cat and dog in this series are developed or integrated as well as they could be.  
  • Bad Luck Cat Mystery by Kay Finch (2 books). I like Hitchcock the cat, but I get annoyed with the main character’s rudeness. I read cozy mysteries to escape the incivility of everyday life and don’t want to follow a character who is unbelievably rude. Also, the stories have some inconsistencies in the characters or their motivations. This might improve as the series continues, but it may be a flaw in the writing & editing process.

The next one was a dud for me.

  • A Nick and Nora Mystery by T.C. LoTempio. I read the first book and thought there were a lot of missed opportunities for the author to show that her main character actually liked her cat. I haven’t read any other books in this series. 

Finally, a good book, but the cat wasn’t a prominent character, despite the cover image. 

  • A Brewing Trouble Mystery by Joyce Tremel. I read Tangled Up in Brew after winning it in a giveaway. I entered the giveaway because the book features a cat prominently on the cover, but the cat doesn’t have much of a presence in the book. I enjoyed the mystery and the writing style but I read other series where the animal is an interesting character that is more prominently featured that I probably won’t continue with this one. The second book also features the cat on the cover, but I don’t know if kitty is prominent in the story.


p.s. Raven said she’s ready for her close-up photos, so the next post will show her newly grown furs. Besides, I have nothing else to share and stall for time while her fur grows!

13 thoughts on “Cozy Mystery Series Rankings”

  1. Great post, I don’t read a lot of cozy mysteries, but when I do, I like the cats to have prominent roles. I can’t wait to see Raven’s new furs 🙂

  2. My human says she can’t imagine creating a whole cozy mystery series! Any story and characters she can think up are pretty much only good for one book.

  3. We usually restrict reading to either library books or stuff in Kindle Unlimited, but mom let’s me buy Ali Brandon’s books cuz we just love them so much. We haven’t read any Laurie Cass, but we have read some of the other two and like them. Unfortunately, we haven’t been able to find their books from the library and they’re not available from Kindle Unlimited. Wish we had a bigger book budget! Too many books and not enough money.

  4. I don’t have a lot of time for reading lately, but when I do I love a good mystery where animals are featured. I appreciate that you are honest about what you like and don’t like!

We enjoy getting comments.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.